Renew, Switch or Refinance?
Renewing keeps your lender, a straight switch moves the same mortgage to a new lender, and a refinance borrows more.
| Compare | Renew | Straight switch | Refinance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lender | Your current lender | A new lender | Current or new lender |
| Balance and amortization | Usually unchanged | Same balance, same remaining amortization | Higher balance and/or longer amortization |
| Re-qualifying | Usually none | Income, credit and property review; generally no stress test with federally regulated lenders | Full qualification, including the stress test |
| Costs | Usually none | Discharge fee; legal and appraisal often covered by the new lender | Legal, appraisal and any penalty if before maturity |
Renew
- Lender
- Your current lender
- Balance and amortization
- Usually unchanged
- Re-qualifying
- Usually none
- Costs
- Usually none
Straight switch
- Lender
- A new lender
- Balance and amortization
- Same balance, same remaining amortization
- Re-qualifying
- Income, credit and property review; generally no stress test with federally regulated lenders
- Costs
- Discharge fee; legal and appraisal often covered by the new lender
Refinance
- Lender
- Current or new lender
- Balance and amortization
- Higher balance and/or longer amortization
- Re-qualifying
- Full qualification, including the stress test
- Costs
- Legal, appraisal and any penalty if before maturity
For a side-by-side walkthrough, read your renewal options compared: renew, switch, negotiate or refinance.
When Can You Switch Without a Penalty?
On your maturity date — so start the switch months earlier and let the new lender fund on that day.
4–6 mo
before maturity: start comparing offers
120 days
about how long many lenders hold a rate
21 days
typical minimum renewal notice — often too late to switch
Switching Before Your Term Ends
Paying out a closed mortgage early usually triggers a penalty, so switch early only when the savings clearly beat it.
- Variable-rate mortgageTypically three months' interest.
- Fixed-rate mortgageTypically the greater of three months' interest or an interest rate differential (IRD) — calculated differently by each lender, and it can be large.
The Stress Test and Straight Switches
Since November 2024, federally regulated lenders don't apply the stress test to a straight switch at renewal — insured or uninsured.
What the new lender still checks
Your income, credit and the property — and it usually orders an appraisal, so a switch isn't automatic.
Keep it straight: same balance, same remaining amortization. Adding money or extending the amortization usually makes it a refinance, with full qualification.
What Switching Costs — and What Switch Offers Cover
Usually modest — and lenders competing for switches often cover the legal and appraisal fees.
- Discharge feeCharged by your current lender to release the mortgage.
- Legal or title feesTo register the new mortgage — often covered by the new lender on a straight switch.
- AppraisalAlso often covered by the new lender.
- Registration typeStandard charge: often transferred by assignment. Collateral charge: usually discharged and re-registered, which can add legal cost.
What is a “switch offer”?
A switch offer is a lender's package for borrowers moving their mortgage: a competitive rate, covered legal and appraisal fees, and sometimes a cash incentive.
Cash incentives often come with conditions, such as repayment if you break the mortgage early. If your mortgage is insured, the default insurance generally stays with the mortgage on a straight switch, so you don't pay a new premium.
How to Compare Renewal and Switch Offers
Compare offers on the whole package, not just the rate.
- Rate and termAnd how long the rate hold lasts.
- Prepayment privilegesHow much you can pay down each year without a penalty.
- Penalty formulaWhat it costs if you break the mortgage early.
- PortabilityIf you might move during the term.
- Charge typeStandard or collateral charge registration.
- Fees and incentivesWhich fees the lender covers, and any conditions.
Use the mortgage renewal calculator to compare your renewal offer with a switch, and see what to compare in renewal rates.
How a Switch Works, Step by Step
Six steps, ideally starting 3 to 4 months before maturity.
Gather your documents
Latest mortgage statement, renewal offer if you have one, ID, recent income documents, property tax bill and home insurance details.
Compare offers
Against your current lender's renewal rate and terms.
Apply and hold a rate
With the new lender, ideally 3 to 4 months before maturity.
Approval and appraisal
The new lender confirms your income and credit and values the property.
Lawyer or title company
Arranges the transfer and pays out your old lender on the maturity date.
Payments start
With the new lender — confirm the first payment date so nothing is missed.
For a printable version, see the straight switch at renewal checklist.
Fixed or Variable at Renewal?
Renewal is a natural time to revisit your rate type — there's no penalty to change it at maturity.
See fixed vs variable at renewal and the full fixed vs variable mortgage guide. Considering variable? Read how adjustable-rate mortgages and prime discounts work.
